top of page

Nonprofit Growth vs. Impact: What Leaders Need to Know for 2027

1 day ago
8 min read

Growth is often viewed as a sign of success in the nonprofit sector. More people served, more programs offered, more services delivered, and larger budgets can all look like evidence that an organization is making a difference.


But growth and impact are not the same thing.


An organization can expand its services without improving the outcomes experienced by the people it serves. It can increase the number of participants while struggling to maintain program quality. It can bring in more funding without knowing which programs are producing the greatest results.


For nonprofit leaders navigating rising community needs, uncertain funding, and limited staff capacity, understanding that distinction is especially important. The goal cannot simply be to do more. It must be to understand whether the work is making a meaningful difference, and whether the organization has the capacity and resources to sustain that difference.


That was a central theme of the Chronicle of Philanthropy's webinar, Scaling Up Without Losing Your Mission. Panelists Don Carpenter, John Simon, and Judith Spitz explored the challenges of growing an organization while protecting its mission, culture, and effectiveness. Their discussion reinforced an important leadership responsibility: growth should be intentional, guided by evidence, and measured against the outcomes an organization exists to achieve.


It is also a point Sheri Chaney Jones, founder and president of SureImpact, reinforced in SureImpact’s recent webinar, Beyond Survival Mode: How Nonprofit Leaders Can Build a Stronger 2027. Her message was direct: nonprofits need more than activity reports and good stories. They need reliable evidence about the difference their work is making.


Measure the Difference, Not Just the Activity

In the Chronicle of Philanthropy webinar, the panelists discussed the importance of ensuring that organizational growth does not come at the expense of mission or effectiveness. That requires leaders to look beyond the visible signs of expansion and ask harder questions about results.

Sheri illustrated this distinction with a simple comparison: McDonald's sells millions of hamburgers each day, far more than Five Guys. But when webinar participants were asked which restaurant makes the better hamburger, many chose Five Guys.


Why? Because the question was about quality, not quantity.


Nonprofits face a similar challenge when communicating their value. Saying an organization served 1,000 children or distributed 500 backpacks describes its activity. Those numbers matter, but they do not tell us whether children improved their reading skills, families became more financially stable, or participants gained the support and resources they needed.


Those are outcomes. They help explain whether the services delivered made a meaningful difference.


As Sheri pointed out, funders and donors are increasingly making decisions in an environment where many organizations are competing for limited resources. An organization that can demonstrate what changed as a result of its work gives funders a clearer understanding of the value of their investment.


The distinction matters internally, too. Outcome data can help leaders recognize when a program is producing the results they expected, when results are declining, and where adjustments may be needed.


Counting activity tells you what your organization did. Measuring outcomes helps you understand what changed.


Keep Growth Connected to Your Mission

Growth can create new opportunities, but it also introduces new demands. More programs and participants require staff time, systems, funding, and organizational capacity. If those demands outpace an organization's ability to deliver effectively, growth can weaken the very work it was intended to strengthen.


During Scaling Up Without Losing Your Mission, John Simon discussed warning signs that an organization may be growing faster than its capacity. These can include declining performance indicators, staff turnover, cultural challenges, and insufficient resources. His perspective highlights why leaders need to monitor organizational health alongside program growth.


Don Carpenter emphasized the responsibility of leaders and boards to protect the mission and ask difficult questions about the organization's direction. That includes considering what the organization should do less of, not just where it should expand.


Judith Spitz's discussion of what she called "passionate accountability" also underscored the importance of holding ourselves and our teams accountable for outcomes, not simply activities.


Together, these perspectives point to a practical leadership question: Does this growth help us achieve our mission more effectively?


Answering that question requires a clear understanding of what success looks like. It also requires meaningful measures that help leaders evaluate whether programs are delivering the intended results.


In our SureImpact webinar, Sheri encouraged nonprofit leaders to establish a clear organizational "North Star": a shared understanding of why the organization exists, what it is working to accomplish, and which impact measures will help it stay focused. When leaders have that clarity, they are better equipped to make decisions based on evidence rather than reacting to every immediate demand.


Build a Culture That Uses Evidence

Collecting data is not the same as building a measurement culture.


A measurement culture exists when an organization aligns its data with its mission and regularly uses that information to make decisions. Data is not collected only because a funder requires a report or because someone needs to count participants at the end of the year. It becomes part of how the organization manages its programs and evaluates its progress.


In Beyond Survival Mode, Sheri shared findings from research she conducted during the period surrounding the Great Recession. Her research examined nonprofit and government organizations' measurement practices and how they related to organizational experiences over a two-year period.


The findings were notable. Among organizations classified as having a high measurement culture, 87% reported increasing their impact and efficiencies during the period studied. That compared with 37% of organizations with a moderate measurement culture and 12% with a low measurement culture.


The research also found differences in reported revenue growth. Sixty-two percent of high measurement-culture organizations reported increased revenue, compared with 18% of moderate-culture organizations and 12% of low-culture organizations.


These findings do not establish that measurement practices caused organizations to increase their impact or revenue. They do, however, show an association between a stronger measurement culture and more positive organizational experiences during a challenging economic period.


Sheri also emphasized that organizational size and budget were not correlated with the ability to build a high-performing measurement culture in her research. Smaller, grassroots organizations could be highly data-driven, while larger organizations with more resources sometimes struggled to use data effectively.


The strongest factor associated with a high measurement culture was the willingness and commitment of leadership, including the board.


That is an important takeaway for nonprofit executives. Building a culture of measurement begins when leaders commit to understanding their results and using evidence to guide the organization.


Measure the Outcomes Your Organization Can Influence

Another important point Sheri made was the need to choose meaningful outcomes at the right stages of a participant's experience.


Nonprofits sometimes focus heavily on long-term outcomes that may take years to materialize and are influenced by many factors beyond the organization's control. For example, a youth literacy program may ultimately contribute to greater economic opportunity, but it cannot reasonably measure that long-term result immediately after a student completes the program.


Sheri encouraged organizations to distinguish between short-term, intermediate, and long-term outcomes.

  • Short-term outcomes describe changes that occur as a result of a participant's involvement in a program. These might include increased knowledge, improved skills, greater awareness, better access to resources, or increased confidence.

  • Intermediate outcomes reflect how participants apply those changes in their lives. Examples might include adopting new behaviors, maintaining positive changes, increasing wages, or achieving greater economic stability.

  • Long-term outcomes are broader changes that may emerge over time and can be influenced by many additional factors. These may be tracked through longer-term follow-up or publicly available data.

Organizations should pay close attention to the short-term and intermediate outcomes their programs are designed to influence. These measures provide useful feedback about whether services are working and where program design or delivery may need to change.


This approach also creates a stronger connection between daily activities and the larger mission. Rather than simply reporting how many services were delivered, organizations can explain how those services contributed to meaningful changes in participants' lives.



Use Evidence to Decide What to Stop, Improve, and Invest In

Reliable outcome data is not just useful for grant applications or annual reports. It is a leadership tool.


In the webinar, Sheri challenged nonprofit leaders to use evidence to make three kinds of decisions:


Stop doing what is no longer effective. Some programs may have stopped producing the intended results as community needs, circumstances, or available resources have changed. Continuing them simply because they have always existed can consume time and funding that could be used more effectively elsewhere.


Improve programs that are not yet achieving the desired outcomes. If a program is producing a 60% success rate when leaders hoped for 85%, that information creates an opportunity to investigate. Are participants receiving enough support? Are there barriers the organization has not addressed? Would a different service approach improve results?


Invest in the programs and strategies that are making the greatest difference. When leaders understand which services are producing strong outcomes, they can make a more informed case for directing additional resources toward them.


This is where measurement becomes part of ongoing management rather than a reporting exercise. Leaders and teams need regular opportunities to review what the data is showing, discuss what they are learning, and make decisions based on that information.


It also changes the conversation with funders. Instead of simply asking for additional resources to meet demand, organizations can explain what they are achieving, where results could improve, and how additional investment could help them achieve stronger outcomes.


Make Sure Your Systems Support the Work

Even when nonprofit leaders understand the importance of measurement, putting it into practice can be difficult without the right processes and tools.


Data may be scattered across spreadsheets, paper files, individual staff members' computers, and disconnected systems. Staff spend hours entering information manually, moving data between platforms, and recreating reports. By the time leadership receives the information, it may already be outdated.


Sheri asked webinar participants to consider how much time their teams spend on these manual processes and what mission-critical work they could accomplish if that time were available for other priorities.


The question is worth asking in every nonprofit organization: Are our current processes helping us understand our impact, or are they making it harder to do so?


Technology should reduce administrative work and make useful information easier to access. The right systems can connect client and service information with outcome data, helping leaders understand who they are serving, what services they receive, and how their circumstances change.


That is the role an integrated impact-management solution can play. SureImpact, for example, brings client management, service tracking, outcome measurement, and reporting together in one platform. Rather than relying on disconnected spreadsheets and reports, nonprofit teams can use connected information to monitor results, identify trends, and make more informed decisions.


Technology alone does not create a measurement culture. Leadership commitment, clear outcomes, and regular conversations about results are still essential. But the right infrastructure can make those practices more manageable and sustainable, especially for organizations working with limited staff and resources.


Make Impact the Measure of Growth

Nonprofit leaders are facing real pressure. Funding is uncertain, community needs continue to evolve, and teams are being asked to accomplish more with limited resources. In that environment, growth can seem like the clearest path forward.


But expanding services without understanding their results can leave organizations with more activity and less clarity.


The discussions in Scaling Up Without Losing Your Mission and Beyond Survival Mode point toward a more intentional approach. Define what success means. Measure the outcomes that matter. Give leaders and boards the information they need to make decisions. And make sure the organization's people, processes, and technology can support the work.


Growth is valuable when it strengthens an organization's ability to fulfill its mission. The real measure of success is not simply how much an organization does, but how much better off people are because of its work.


Continue the Conversation

As you set your priorities for 2027, consider whether your organization has the strategy, data, and tools needed to turn those priorities into measurable results. Knowing what’s working, where resources are making the greatest difference, and how to communicate your outcomes can help you make stronger decisions and position your organization for the future.


Let’s talk about your goals for 2027. Schedule a strategy call with SureImpact to discuss your organization's priorities, outcome measurement needs, and challenges with managing and communicating impact. We'll explore where better data and stronger impact-management practices could help you make informed decisions, demonstrate your results to funders, and focus resources on the work that makes the greatest difference.



bottom of page