top of page

The Hidden Power of Unsolicited Charitable Giving for Nonprofits

In the complex landscape of nonprofit fundraising, unsolicited charitable giving often seems like a serendipitous boon, akin to stumbling upon a hidden treasure. However, recent insights and studies challenge the notion that such windfalls are mere strokes of luck. Instead, they are often the results of strategic preparation and organizational excellence. In this post, we'll explore why unsolicited giving is not only a significant opportunity for nonprofits but also a clear indicator of their operational effectiveness and impact.

The Foundation of Success: Organizational Clarity and Impact

The narrative around unsolicited gifts began to shift with insights like those from Karen Eber Davis in her LinkedIn article "I Was Wrong about Nonprofit Windfall & Unsolicited Major Gifts." Initially, many in the nonprofit sector, including Davis, viewed these gifts as rare, almost lottery-like occurrences. The reality, she discovered, was quite different. Nonprofits that attract unsolicited gifts typically exhibit a set of common traits that make them stand out. These include a laser-clear mission, vision, and values; smart strategies that lead toward the vision with sustainable funding; standout executive leadership; and robust, scalable processes that generate mission success, community visibility, and solid business operations.

Adding to these traits, it is crucial for nonprofits to establish measurable metrics to track and prove their impact. Metrics not only demonstrate the effectiveness of a nonprofit’s programs but also reassure potential donors that their contributions will lead to tangible change. This transparency in showcasing success through data is increasingly becoming a deciding factor for donors when choosing where to allocate their unsolicited gifts.

Expanding the Charitable Pie: Insights from Vanguard Charitable

The potential of unsolicited gifts to increase overall charitable contributions is supported by data from Vanguard Charitable's study, which shows how donor-advised funds (DAFs) facilitate both expected and unexpected giving. According to the study, donors who engage in unexpected giving through their DAFs contribute 39% more than those who stick strictly to planned donations. Moreover, unexpected gifts often lead to increased regular giving, with a 24% rise in prioritized, ongoing contributions from these donors.

Mitch Stein highlights the importance of these findings in his LinkedIn post, discussing how unsolicited or "inspiration-based" giving does not displace other donations but instead adds to the donor's total philanthropic output. This debunks the common fear in fundraising that adding another nonprofit to a donor’s list might decrease the funds available for others. In reality, the introduction of unsolicited giving options can significantly "increase the pie" of charitable contributions.

The Role of Communication and Donor Engagement

Lisa Greer's experiences with unsolicited donations, as shared in her post about giving "just because," underscore the importance of effective communication and donor engagement strategies. She notes the occasional confusion among nonprofits when receiving an unsolicited gift, which can lead to awkward interactions rather than gratitude and engagement. This highlights a missed opportunity for nonprofits to forge lasting relationships with spontaneous donors.

Strategies for Attracting Unsolicited Gifts

Given the transformative potential of unsolicited gifts, how can nonprofits position themselves to attract such generosity? Here are several strategies:

  1. Enhance Visibility and Communication: Ensure that your nonprofit's mission and impact are highly visible and easily understandable. This can be achieved through an effective online presence, clear messaging, and compelling, data-driven impact stories that resonate with potential donors’ values and interests.

  2. Implement Robust Data Tracking: Develop and maintain robust systems for tracking and reporting the impact of donations. Transparently sharing these results with the public can attract donors who are looking for proven effectiveness in their contributions.

  3. Foster Executive Leadership: Cultivate leaders who are not only visionaries but also capable of driving the organization towards its strategic goals. Effective leadership is often a key factor that donors consider when deciding to contribute unexpectedly.

  4. Engage in Community Building: Active engagement in community affairs increases a nonprofit's visibility and relevance. It also positions the organization as a key player in addressing local issues, making it more likely to receive support without direct solicitation.

  5. Simplify Giving Processes: As Mitch Stein suggests, integrating easy donation processes, such as DAF payments, can facilitate spontaneous giving by making the act as effortless as possible for the donors.


Unsolicited charitable giving represents a critical growth area for nonprofits, far beyond the simplistic view of it being mere luck. It is an affirmation of an organization's reputation, effectiveness, and impact. By focusing on strategic visibility, impactful communication, and operational excellence, nonprofits can position themselves to not only attract unsolicited gifts but also expand their overall funding and reach. In doing so, they harness the power of spontaneous generosity to further their mission and multiply their impact on the community and beyond.

For a step-by-step guide for sharing a data-driven impact story, check out our “Ultimate Guide to Impact Measurement.” 


bottom of page